Saturday, September 17, 2011

It’s a Gift (1934) **

it's a gift

W.C. Fields was a deadpan comedic genius. He became famous as a vaudeville performer in the Ziegfeld Follies and most of his films borrow from gags he performed on the stage. It’s a Gift (1934) relies heavily on a number of his revue staples, as well as from his 1926 silent film, It’s the Old Army Game. In Fields’ world everything was fair game when it came to comedy. He had an antipathy toward most things domestic and traditional—even the handicapped were not off limits, as witnessed by his treatment of the blind and deaf Mr. Muckle. These comedic traits made Fields a unique Hollywood performer—plus, he could act, write, and juggle (he was a master juggler). His gift for improvisation can only be compared to that of Steve Carell’s today. Yes, he had a bit of a drinking problem…so what, Mozart had this same issue and by all accounts he was a pretty good musician.

its a giftDirectorNorman McLeod was responsible for keeping Fields on track in It’s a Gift…he’d become an expert at dealing with improvisational ex-vaudevillians through his work with the Marx Brothers as well as his earlier films with Fields. The plot revolves around Harold Bissonette (Fields), a New Jersey grocer who hates his store, customers (especially Mr. Muckle, played by the hilarious Charles Sellon), neighbors, and family (especially his wife Amelia, played by the outstanding Kathleen Howard). Harold’s dream is to own an orange grove and ranch in California, and so when he learns that he may be inheriting some money, hope begins to seep into his mind. Never mind that his family has totally different ideas about where their newfound money might be used.

There a number of memorable scenes in this film. The first one is the
bathroom scene, where Harold is carefully shaving with a straight razor while his daughter Mildred (Jean Rouverol) goes about her business as though he isn’t
itsthere. Several times she comes perilously close to hitting her father’s arm, thus helping him slit his own throat—metaphorically, that’s what a daughter can drive you to. After Mildred fully monopolizes the medicine cabinet mirror, Harold relies on a makeshift mirror on a light pull cord, which sways back and forth. Imagine trying to shave like that? Fields’ coming timing is superb…without the aid of much dialogue.

itsagThe second scene that stands out is the enormously funny grocery encounter between Harold and Mr. Muckle. Blind and deaf (he uses an ear trumpet) Mr. Muckle has a habit of breaking Harold’s glass door with his cane, which he wildly waves back and forth, and just about everything else that is encased in glass. It is side-splitting funny to watch him drop light bulbs on the floor while Harold tries to be as polite as possible. Later, once the tornado that is Mr. Muckle has left the store, we meet baby Ellwood (Baby LeRoy), his neighbor’s son.  Harold refers to him as blood poison, and for good reason: baby Ellwood is a holy terror who likes to throw things at Harold and play in molasses.

The third standout scene happens when Harold attempts to sleep on his porch. After listening to Amelia gripe about his plans to move to California for hours, Harold decides to sleep on the porch swing. Not only is the swing squeaky, but it is dilapidated as well. When he tries to lie down on it one of the chains break and he tries to sleep with vlcsnap-341349his head on the ground and his feet in the air. Noisy delivery men, neighbors, and an imposing insurance salesman (T. Roy Barnes) also disturb his slumber, but it is baby Ellwood that is the real bedbug. Grapes and icepicks are his weapons of noise (and near death for Harold). If you don’t laugh when Harold confronts Ellwood with the icepick then you don’t have a sense of humor.

And, finally, the road trip California has numerous laugh-out-loud gags as well. The picnic scene on the private estate is highly comical, especially the gags with the can opener and statues. And, Amelia’s reaction when they reach the sun-itsaparched land that’s supposed to be their orange grove is one of Kathleen Howard’s best scenes.

I really enjoy watching W.C. Fields. My favorite type of comedy is a sophisticated one, but I also enjoy deadpan and gag comedy as well. I don’t think there was a better deadpan comic during the early years of Hollywood than Fields. I once read that Louise Brooks (who worked with Fields at the Follies and in some early films) thought he was much funnier on the stage than the screen because his brilliance couldn’t be chopped up by a film editor on the open stage. It must have been a sight to behold, because his movies are pretty darn funny—imagine seeing him live without the constraints of censors. 


  1. Kim, I LOVE W.C. Fields. I too wish I could have seen him live on stage -- what a treat that would have been! I think this is a great review of one of his best movies. You are dead on about the individual scenes. Fields and children are hilarious, and his wife is a hoot. The blind man, the daughter, all wonderful supporting players.

    Fields was a comic marvel. When my Dad would have a bad day, he would say "On the whole, I'd rather be in Philadelphia!" That's our tribute to Fields.

  2. Love Fields and "It's a Gift" is one of my favorites of his...laugh-out-loud funny even after many viewings...great write-up, Kim...

    Just yesterday I came upon Dick Cavett's latest NYT blog - in which he referenced Fields on drinking..."we lost our corkscrew and had to live on food and water for several days."

  3. As a fellow Fields fan (say that 10 times fast), I really enjoyed your post on IT'S A GIFT - it's also one of my Fields faves (somehow The Great Man brings out the alliteratist in me). Fields had a great foil in Kathleen Howard in this film (she's equally magnificent in THE MAN ON THE FLYING TRAPEZE) - my treasured line in IT'S A GIFT is when WC confronts the man who wants to buy his orange grove. "You're drunk!" the man snaps. "And you're crazy," Fields replies, "But I'll be sober tomorrow; and you'll be crazy the rest of your life." A great way to win an argument!

  4. I was not too carried away by It's a Gift, but I guess it was partly because this was my first Fields movie (I since seen quite a few) and partly because there is very little forward momentum in the story. I get the feeling he is stuck in his place, but that is of course also the point. No matter what he does he is trapped whith that wife of his, his children, customers, neighbours etc. I guess I just genuinely felt sorry for his character and wished for him to move on to California to start a new life.

    1. Fields films are gag films, which to me says they are not must see worthy. They have some funny bits, but there is nothing substantial to his movies.