This is vanity at its most pretentious. Fellini had his 8 1/2 (1963) and director Bob Fosse had his All That Jazz (1979). Like Fellini, there is much to like about a Fosse production, but there are also, like Fellini, quibbles to be had, too. Films with an autobiographical bent can sometimes become too fantastical, and, well, self-indulgent—there are elements of both in All That Jazz.
Joe Gideon (Roy Scheider) is a successful director of films and musicals, as well as a gifted dancer and choreographer. But, he’s also a chain-smoking, womanizing workaholic on the verge of a massive coronary. He starts his days off by listening to Vivaldi’s Concerto in G, popping dexedrine, and smoking a pack of cigarettes before breakfast. In what can only be described as an extended ostentatious reflection, the audience gets to eavesdrop as Gideon discusses his life with a scantily-clad Angel of Death (Jessica Lange)—with over-the-top Fosse musical numbers scattered in for good measure. By the end of the film you are either pleased as punch with the ending or asking yourself WTF just happened—or perhaps both.
Well, it wouldn’t be a Fosse film if there wasn’t singing and dancing, so let’s start with the musical numbers. I love musicals, but for some reason I didn’t really like any of the numbers in All That Jazz. Sure, I loved hearing George Benson’s “On Broadway” at the start of the film, but found myself overly-taxed by watching the infamous cattle call at the beginning. Then, there’s “Take Off with Us”. The first part is palatable, the second part is one step above soft-core porn, and, as such, not my cup of tea. And, finally, there is the series of numbers relating to Gideon’s impending demise: “After You’re Gone”, “You Better Change Your Ways”, “Who’s Sorry Now,” “Some of These Days,” and “Bye Bye Life”. The production designs and costumes are interesting (both won Oscars), but the musical numbers seemed lacking.
Then, there’s the acting. Scheider was nominated for an Oscar, and overall I think he does a nice job of showing what a complete hedonistic ass Gideon is. I suppose before he started making Jaws sequels he was a decent actor. Still, I didn’t think his was the standout performance. I particularly enjoyed Leland Palmer as Audrey, Gideon’s ex wife, and Erzsebet Foldi as Michelle, Gideon’s daughter. My two favorite parts in the film involve the scenes where the two of them dance with (or in the case of Audrey, around) Gideon. The complexity of his relationships with Audrey and Michelle shine in these two particular instances, and give much more depth to Gideon’s personality. As for the rest of the cast, they are passable—except Deborah Geffner as Victoria, who plays her character as though she is really in a soft-core porno.
So, I’m not exactly raving on this, am I? Still, I gave it a **1/2 rating, so I guess I should say why. I think Fosse tells the story in a highly unusual and entertaining way. Yes, it can be pretentious at times, but the way he puts all of the varying parts of the story together to meet at a pretty startling conclusion is inspired storytelling in my opinion. Alan Heim won an Oscar for his editing of this, but I suspect Fosse had a heavy hand in every single cut. Sometimes originality doesn’t work, but that is not the case with All That Jazz.
I see the connection between this and Fellini, but I disagree with its self-indulgence. This is much more a warts-and-all autobiography. Fosse puts his faults on display and invites everyone to realize what a bastard he is. There's a level of honesty there that I find impressive. And I love the last half hour.ReplyDelete
I thought you didn't like musicals? LOL! You must like the more unusual ones.Delete
I do like some--I absolutely love Singin' in the Rain, for instance, and I enjoy My Fair Lady. I'm more on my guard with musicals, though.Delete
This one, though...it avoids the problems I tend to have with musicals by making the musical numbers actually work within the context of the reality of the world the film is in. Since it overcomes my immediate objections, I'm much more able to view it as a film, and I think it hits on all cylinders.
I see your point about how musicals fit in numbers. Singin' in the Rain is brilliant.Delete
Hi, Kim! You and I are in agreement about the facets of the movie you liked, but boy we couldn't be farther apart about the musical numbers, Scheider's acting, all the rest. I thought this movie was brilliant in every way. I really did, and that doesn't often happen to me. Of course, dark dark humor suits me the best -- in my family, we call it coffin humor, which certainly applies here! LOL! I thought the Hospital Hallucination scene was unmatchable. It's funny, because I don't usually like "soft porn" stuff either, but "Take Off With Us" was such a powerful statement about not only Gideon's sexual promiscuity, but also the sexual revolution of the time it was made. Plus, I thought both halves of the number were great music and dance.ReplyDelete
Anyway, we may disagree about a lot, but your article is, as always, thought-provoking and well done.
Becky: as always, thanks for the nice comments. You are right, there is a lot of dark (coffin) humor in All That Jazz. I usually like it, and I think it is used pretty well here. I like the first part of "Take Off with Us"--Fosse was very original in his choreography. As usual, we can't always agree on everything.ReplyDelete