While Sweden generally does not suffer from extreme heat temperatures, I can find no other explanation as to why so many characters in director David Fincher’s The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo (2011) are so diabolically demented than this: Satan sleeps in Sweden. While the film is cloaked in a rather riveting plot about a serial killer, there is no getting around the fact that that the story is filled with graphically disturbing scenes and amoral characters.
Based on the international best-selling Swedish novel of the same name by Stieg Larsson, The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo asks the question: what happened to Harriet Vanger (Joely Richardson) 40 years ago? Disgraced journalist Mikael Blomkvist (Daniel Craig) is asked by Henrik Vanger (Christopher Plummer) to investigate his niece, Harriet’s, disappearance and assumed murder. Whilst combing through boxes of documents, Mikael discovers a notebook containing a list of undecipherable names and numbers, which he thinks is connected to Harriet’s disappearance. Part of his investigation requires his questioning Vanger family members about what they remember about the day Harriet disappeared. Let me tell you, the entire Vanger family is a study in emotional instability and Type A-personalities—almost all of them live on the same massive island compound in separate homes and refuse to speak to one another. When Mikael’s investigation hits a snag he enlists the help of Lisbeth Salander (Rooney Mara), a gifted computer hacker.
Lisbeth is the girl with the dragon tattoo—as well as many other tattoos and piercings. Let’s just say it—she’s a crazy bi-sexual with anti-social tendencies who dresses like a punk obsessed with the color black. You’d think that the most disturbing images about the hunt for a serial killer would be connected to the murders, but not here. No, we are treated to two graphic rape scenes. In one, Lisbeth is sodomized by her reprehensible 
state guardian Nils Bjurman (Yorick van Wageningen)—it’s the price she has to pay to get him to allow her to have her own money. In the second, Lisbeth tasers Nils, rapes him with a giant dildo and then proceeds to tattoo “I Am a Rapist” on his chest. Mikael, of course, takes her away from this sick world and into the demented Vanger world, where first a father is a serial rapist and killer and then his son. Quite frankly, it’s one “Ick” after another—and in between “icks”, we get to see Lisbeth and Mikael have soft porn sex.
So, after my description of the film you are probably wondering why I gave it 2-and-a-half stars if I was so repulsed by it? Well, no matter how deplorable and unlikable most of the characters are and how graphically disturbing some of the images are, you cannot get around the fact that the story is compelling. When Mikael and Lisbeth discover the truth about what happened to Harriet you are shocked (even though when you reflect on how screwed up the Vanger family is it does make perfectly sick sense).
Although Mara was nominated for a Best Actress Oscar, overall there were no striking performances. The film is filled with gifted actors: Plummer, Richardson, and Stellan Skarsgård to name a few, and there is a steadiness to the film because of this. Yet, other than the character of Lisbeth (and even she is limited), Fincher presents his characters as staid, cool Swedes. 
Attempting to channel Bergman was a mistake for a former music video director from Colorado. Fincher does much better making films with American sensibilities, and should leave Swedish existentialism to the master (and, on occasion, his American stalker and imitator Woody Allen).
Overall, I found The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo graphically disturbing, but found myself immersed in its overall plot. I didn’t like one single character, yet was still somewhat attached to the outcome of a few of them. Simply put: I found the entire film disturbing—was that a good thing? Who knows…
I saw the original 2009 version (Swedish) with Michael Nyqvist (not quite Daniel Craig) and Noomi Rapace. Though I didn't care much for the graphic violence and disturbing subject matter, the actors and mood/atmosphere did hold my attention. I've tried to watch the 2011 remake with Daniel Craig and Rooney Mara but haven't been able to stick with it to the end. Yet. Will try again.
ReplyDeleteIf you thought the first one was violent, wait until you watch the second. Ick.
DeleteI have seen both the Swedish version and American version and I actually liked the American version a little better. I am a fan of the book and, while the film doesn't quite measure up, I thought they did a pretty good job. I would say that Lisbeth is a pretty hard character to nail down, so I think both actresses did creditable jobs.
ReplyDeleteThere's a lot going on with Lisbeth, so I agree, Mara did a credible job of portraying such a disturbed character.
DeleteI liked this one a bit more than the Swedish version, but seeing that one didn't help me with this one. In fact, it probably made this one's effect on me hit less than it originally could have, had I walked into it blindly. Good review Kim.
ReplyDeleteSometimes that's how it is with remakes (or American takes on films). The revelation of who the sicko is is the best thing for me, so if you already knew from seeing the Swedish version or having read the book, I suppose it would fall a tad flat.
DeleteI've seen both versions.... and, even though the Sedish version comes with sub-titles, it's the way better version. I read all three of the books too.
ReplyDeleteGood to know. I haven't seen the Swedish version, so I think I'll have to check it out.
Delete